John's Notes

Thursday, July 06, 2006

 

Distance-based fares for Sacramento light rail

1. Inequities in existing RT fare structure

A major inequity in the existing Sacramento RT fare structure is tacitly allowing unlimited rides on light rail for two hours, but only one bus ride for the same fare. A similar inequity exists for "transfers", which allow unlimited rides on light rail and a final ride on bus when the transfer has to be surrendered. A consultant's study in 2005 recommended eliminating transfers, and restricting light rail travel to the direction away from the station of origin. This policy would largely remove the inequities between bus and light rail travel.

Bus operators generally support the elimination of transfers, but they are popular with riders. RT's compromise in 2005 was to institute a very mild two-level fare scheme, by instituting a nominal charge of 25 cents for a transfer. This fee is far too low, and should be raised to about one-half of the base (single-ride) fare. To make this increase more palatable to riders, and to avoid difficulties in implementation, the transfer should be treated as a 2-hour pass for unlimited rides on buses and light rail. Furthermore, the consultant's recommendation to restrict light rail travel away from the station of origin should be adopted.

Sacramento RT should also reconsider another of the consultant's recommendations, to introduce a two-level pricing structure for light rail travel. That is, a single-ride fare would cover a "short" light rail trip, while a longer trip would require a surcharge. In the context of treating a "transfer" as a 2-hour pass, a longer light rail trip would not require another, special ticket, but merely a valid 2-hour pass.

2. Strawman example

For simplicity, this example assumes the single-ride, base fare is raised to $2.00, while the 2-hour pass is priced at $3.00. The base fare is good for a single bus ride, or a "short" light rail ride. A 2-hour pass is needed for any other trip, including a "long" light rail ride. The consultant's suggestion that a "short" ride be a trip through 14 stations or less is about right, but the number of stations might need adjusting. An alternative would be to establish a small number of zones, and a "short" ride being a trip entirely within one zone or two adjacent zones. For illustration, there might be six zones:An exception to the two-zone rule might be made for trips between zones C and D, which would be priced at the base fare.

One modificationto this scheme that might be considered is to allow unlimited trips on light rail within a single zone for one or two hours for the price of a base fare. RT might also consider issuing distance-based monthly passes for light rail trips only, good for travel between two specified stations, with a surcharge for travel outside of the designated limits. It would require a special machine to issue these passes, but they could be distributed through mail as well as in person at an RT office.

Archives

October 2005   May 2006   July 2006   November 2006   March 2009   August 2011   November 2011  

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Subscribe to Posts [Atom]